Top court upholds emergency church closure

Key points: 

  • The Judicial Council ruled that California-Pacific Conference leaders complied with denominational law in a controversial church closure.
  • Earlier this year, the conference closed a small East Los Angeles church that had signed a multimillion-dollar agreement to lease its land for affordable housing.
  • The conference said it had concerns about whether the funds had proper oversight and decided to act to protect denominational assets. 
  • In a concurrence, members of The United Methodist Church’s top court raised concerns about part of the church-closure provision. Those concerns do not alter the outcome of this case.

The California-Pacific Conference complied with denominational law in its emergency closure of an eastern Los Angeles church, The United Methodist Church’s top court ruled in a decision released Nov. 18.

However, a concurrence to the decision — signed by all five clergy on the nine-member Judicial Council — raised concerns about the church-closure provision itself.

In Decision 1526, the Judicial Council examined Bishop Dottie Escobedo-Frank’s responses to questions raised at this year’s California-Pacific Annual Conference about the closure of La Trinidad United Methodist Church under exigent circumstances.

Bishops routinely face questions of law during the sessions at which they preside. The Book of Discipline — the denomination’s policy book — requires that any bishop’s decision of law must go before the Judicial Council for review.

“The decisions of law on the six questions presented to the bishop are affirmed,” the church court determined in Decision 1526.

“The California-Pacific Annual Conference correctly followed the requirements of ¶ 2549.4(b)” in the denomination’s Book of Discipline, the decision said. That disciplinary provision governs church closures under “exigent” — that is, pressing — circumstances.

The ruling follows the Judicial Council holding an online oral hearing Oct. 22 and opting to extend its deliberations to Nov. 16.

The Judicial Council’s decision also comes as multiple lawsuits involving United Methodist church-property disputes make their way through civil courts across the U.S. Among the most high-profile of these disputes is the litigation around Dallas’ prominent Highland Park congregation, where about 90% of voting members recently supported cutting ties with the denomination. 

Subscribe to our
e-newsletter

Like what you're reading and want to see more? Sign up for our free UM News Digests featuring important news and events in the life of The United Methodist Church.

Keep me informed!

In deciding such legal matters, civil court judges often refer to rulings by the denomination’s Judicial Council. 

At issue in this case was how California-Pacific Conference leaders handled the closure and disposition of assets at La Trinidad, a congregation that for generations has ministered among the Hispanic community of eastern Los Angeles.

In 2023, the small congregation struck a deal to lease its property for an affordable-housing development for seniors while retaining a space for worship on property. All told, the church was to receive $3.3 million under the ground-lease agreement.

However, conference leadership increasingly became concerned about a lack of oversight for the funds. Worship attendance declined to an average of 10 people. Also, when a new pastor was appointed to the church in July 2025, the church did not initially approve his salary and benefits package, and for two months, he relied on the conference’s West District for his compensation. The conference also said some duly elected church members were excluded from church decision-making. 

Conference and district leaders said they also did not receive requested financial records about the disposition of the initial funds the church received from its lease agreement. 

Matters reached a crisis point in December 2025 when the final lease payment of $3.1 million became payable. The conference said it arranged to obtain the physical check and retain it at the conference office while working on measures to safeguard the funds. But in January this year, church members arranged for the escrow company to void the check and transfer $3.1 million to a credit union account instead.

That’s when conference leaders began proceedings to close the congregation under “exigent circumstances.”

The conference also brought a lawsuit in civil court to recover the roughly $3.1 million and has since recovered about $2.8 million. 

Of those funds, about $2 million is now in a California-Pacific Foundation account designated for the long-term support of Hispanic ministries in East Los Angeles. 

The conference deposited the remaining $800,000 in a credit-union account for purposes that included satisfying outstanding local church obligations, supporting pastoral leadership and funding a new Hispanic ministry known as Nueva Esperanza, or New Hope. The new mission congregation is under the same pastor previously appointed to La Trinidad. 

The affordable senior housing remains under development. 

Much of the oral hearing dealt with the removal of church officers and the ongoing civil court case. However, the Judicial Council said its main task was to review the issues of church law presented. 

“The role of the Judicial Council thus includes the review of processes to determine whether a part of the Church has complied with applicable requirements,” the decision said. 

Those applicable requirements are in the Discipline’s Paragraph 2549.4(b). That provision says that at any time between annual conference sessions, conference leaders — including the bishop, a majority of district superintendents and the appropriate district board of church location — “may, in their sole discretion, declare that exigent circumstances exist that require immediate protection of the local church’s property, for the benefit of the denomination.”

The same provision goes on to say that with such a closure, “title to all the real and personal, tangible and intangible property of the local church shall immediately vest in the annual conference board of trustees who may hold or dispose of such property in its sole discretion, subject to any standing rule of the annual conference.”

The Discipline also says that when it next meets, “the annual conference shall decide whether to formally close the local church.”

All those steps happened in this case, the church court concluded. In June this year, after debate on the conference floor, a majority of California-Pacific Annual Conferences members voted for La Trinidad to close. 

Thus, the church court ruled, the conference followed the requirements of church law. 

Previously, the Judicial Council has ruled that Paragraph 2549.4(b) contains safeguards including the requirement that multiple conference leaders sign off on the interim closure and that the annual conference as a whole must approve the formal closure. 

The California-Pacific Conference applied those safeguards in this case, the church court concluded. 

In other previous decisions, the Judicial Council has ruled that the denomination’s church-closure provision cannot be used as a back door to let churches exit the denomination with property. Those decisions still stand, the church court said.

The Judicial Council, the decision said, “will not second-guess the judgment of the annual conference if the requirements of ¶ 2549.4(b) are properly invoked, followed, and approved by the members to the annual conference session where the closure is approved.”

While agreeing that the conference properly followed church law, five church court members in the ruling’s concurrence did question whether part of Paragraph 2549.4(b) passes muster under the denomination’s constitution.

Specifically, the concurrence objected to “the sole discretion authority” the church law grants to the conference board of trustees to dispose of a local church’s property before the full annual conference votes on the closure. 

“We view ¶ 2549.4(b)’s sole discretion authority … to be an unlawful delegation of authority that circumvents the annual conference’s authority,” the concurrence said.

“Therefore, unless ¶ 2549.4(b)’s process regarding the disposal of local church property is carried out in the sequence of a closure determination, followed by the annual conference members’ approval of the closure, and only then disposal of property in accordance with annual conference policy, we believe the process may be unconstitutional and void as applied.”

The signers of the concurrence include the Revs. Susan T. Henry-Crowe, Judicial Council president; Angela Brown, secretary; Timothy Bruster, Taylor Denyer and Jonathan Ulanday. The full council has nine members including four lay members, and six votes are needed to strike down part of the Discipline as unconstitutional. 

The concurrence stressed that the church court is not dealing with the constitutionality of Paragraph 2549.4(b) at this time. 

“The constitutionality, meaning, application, and effect of the remaining provisions of that subparagraph may be the subject of a future decision of law or request for declaratory decision presented,” the concurrence said, “but that is not within the review of the bishop’s decision of law in this matter … .”

Hahn is assistant news editor for UM News. Linda Bloom, a retired assistant news editor for UM News, contributed to this story. Contact them at (615) 742-5470 or newsdesk@umnews.org. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free UM News Digest.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Subscribe Now
Judicial Council
The United Methodist Judicial Council has postponed a ruling related to a dispute over a church closing in California, but issued two memorandums on other agenda items during its Oct. 21-23 fall meeting. Photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

Top court delays ruling related to California church closure

The United Methodist Judicial Council will continue deliberations on Nov. 16 concerning a decision of law by Bishop Dottie Escobedo-Frank regarding the closure of La Trinidad United Methodist Church in California.
Disaster Relief
Lahaina United Methodist Church on Maui lost its sanctuary in the deadly Maui wildfires, but its congregation never lost its faith. Photo by Lilla Marigza, UM News.

3 years after wildfire, hope spreads in Lahaina

The sanctuary is gone, but the congregation never stopped gathering. At Lahaina United Methodist Church, faith, volunteers and a vision for the future are helping a community rebuild.
Immigration
Friends and relatives in Bucaramanga, Colombia, hold a vigil July 14 for Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero, a Colombian national who was fatally shot by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement officer in Maine. The Maine Immigrants’ Rights Coalition said Durán Guerrero was legally authorized to work in the U.S. Photo by Jaime Moreno, AP.

Amid ICE killings, churches defend immigrants

United Methodists are caring for frightened neighbors after federal immigration enforcement fatally shot two people in less than a week. Church leaders also are trying to help people who have seen their legal status stripped.

United Methodist Communications is an agency of The United Methodist Church

©2026 United Methodist Communications. All Rights Reserved