Top court delays ruling related to California church closure

Key points:

  • The United Methodist Judicial Council will continue deliberations on Nov. 16 concerning a decision of law by California-Pacific Bishop Dottie Escobedo-Frank.
  • The bishop’s decision is regarding the closure of La Trinidad United Methodist Church in Los Angeles. 
  • The church court issued memorandums on two other matters during its fall meeting Oct. 21-23.

The United Methodist Judicial Council has postponed a ruling related to a dispute over a church closing in California, but issued two memorandums on other agenda items during its Oct. 21-23 fall meeting. 

The denomination’s top court did hold a scheduled Oct. 22 oral hearing on Zoom concerning a decision of law by United Methodist Bishop Dottie Escobedo-Frank, who leads the denomination’s California-Pacific Annual Conference, regarding the closure of La Trinidad United Methodist Church in Los Angeles. The decision of law centers on the use of Discipline ¶ 2549.4(b).

But Judicial Council members agreed Oct. 23 to continue deliberations at 10 a.m. Nov. 16.

The Judicial Council continues its review of this matter and is not yet in a position to issue a decision, the council stated. The council will reconvene on Nov. 16 for further consideration of the parties’ submissions and statements at the oral hearing. A ruling may not be issued on that date but will be sent to all parties promptly once the decision is reached.

Subscribe to our
e-newsletter

Like what you're reading and want to see more? Sign up for our free UM News Digests featuring important news and events in the life of The United Methodist Church.

Keep me informed!

In other business, the Judicial Council gave further direction, in Memorandum 1524, to the Southeastern Jurisdiction Committee on Appeals related to the membership case in the Western North Carolina Annual Conference. 

The council’s earlier Memorandum 1522 had asked the appeals committee to provide a more complete ruling on the procedural fair process issues raised in the appeal and determine whether the right of appeal had been forfeited. 

In Memorandum 1524, the Judicial Council asks the committee on appeals to comply with Memorandum 1522 by issuing a new decision on the procedural fair process issues within three months.

Memorandum 1525 responds to a request for a declaratory decision submitted by the New England Annual Conference regarding the resident bishop’s handling of two complaints received in February 2025.

Judicial Council stated it does not have jurisdiction to decide the issues in the request for declaratory decision. 

Bloom is a retired assistant news editor for UM News. She lives in New York.

News media contact: Julie Dwyer at newsdesk@umnews.org. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free UM News Digest.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Subscribe Now
Annual Conferences
The Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia has stopped a lawsuit by 33 United Methodist congregations over property. In the meantime, the West Virginia Conference says it remains committed to supporting the churches. Photo by J. Alex Wilson, courtesy of the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia.

State supreme court blocks church-property suit

The West Virginia Supreme Court stopped a lawsuit by 33 United Methodist congregations over property. In the meantime, the West Virginia Conference says it remains committed to supporting the churches.
Congregations
Bishop Rubén Saenz Jr. gives the sermon during morning worship at the United Methodist Leadership Gathering Oct. 21 at Knox United Church in Calgary, Canada. The Horizon Texas Conference bishop announced Oct. 29 that he has appointed a new pastor to Highland Park United Methodist Church in Dallas after the church held a congregational vote to cut ties with the denomination. Photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

Bishop names new pastor to Highland Park

Bishop Rubén Saenz Jr. is making plans to care for Highland Park members who wish to stay United Methodist. In letters to both Highland Park lay leaders and congregants, he also maintained that this week’s congregational vote to cut ties with the denomination is not valid under church law.
Congregations
Members of Highland Park United Methodist Church, which began on the Southern Methodist University campus in Dallas 110 years ago, voted on Oct. 25-26 to sever ties with The United Methodist Church. Photo courtesy of Highland Park United Methodist Church via Wikipedia.

Highland Park votes to leave United Methodist Church

After two days of voting, members of the Dallas congregation overwhelmingly approved a resolution severing ties with The United Methodist Church. More than 90% voted in favor of the move, according to the church.

United Methodist Communications is an agency of The United Methodist Church

©2026 United Methodist Communications. All Rights Reserved