Formula for calculating number of bishops eliminated


Key Points:

  • Newly passed legislation guarantees at least five bishops per jurisdiction.
  • General Conference 2016 created the Jurisdictional Study Committee to examine the number, boundaries and missional priorities of the jurisdictions.
  • “Let’s face it,” Susan Brumbaugh said. “Our membership is changing rapidly, and that formula is no longer serving us well.”

Jurisdictions across the United States will have more say about the number of bishops they need, thanks to new legislation that passed during General Conference.

By May 1 of the gathering, the body had rejected one but passed four of the five petitions recommended by the Jurisdictional Study Committee, eliminating the formula for calculating bishops while guaranteeing at least five bishops per jurisdiction.

Subscribe to our
e-newsletter

Like what you're reading and want to see more? Sign up for our free daily and weekly digests of important news and events in the life of The United Methodist Church.

Keep me informed!

General Conference 2016 created the Jurisdictional Study Committee to examine the number, boundaries and missional priorities of the jurisdictions. A diverse group, the committee comprises clergy, laity and bishops from all five jurisdictions.

Lonnie Chafin, Fred Brewington and Susan Brumbaugh presented their report to the body Tuesday, April 30, noting they had concluded the current jurisdictions and boundaries are appropriate as is, and that the jurisdictions themselves are in a better position to assess their need for numbers of bishops.

Key is their assessment that the formula The United Methodist Church had used for calculating bishops in each jurisdiction no longer is an accurate reflection of leadership needs.

“Let’s face it,” Brumbaugh said. “Our membership is changing rapidly, and that formula is no longer serving us well.”

Four legislative items passed Tuesday and Wednesday. Three were included in consent calendars, and one passed on the floor with a 666-43 vote. These did the following:

  • Eliminated the formula for calculating bishops in each jurisdiction;
  • Established a minimum number of bishops (five) for each jurisdiction;
  • Established a process for jurisdictions to request any additional bishops needed, which means those jurisdictions who believe they need more than five bishops can discern the number they need;
  • Established that if a jurisdiction wants more than five bishops, the jurisdiction, not the denomination, will pay for those additional bishop costs; and
  • Authorized the Interjurisdictional Committee on Episcopacy to receive and act on any requests from jurisdictions for additional bishops.

The one item that did not pass pertained to episcopal office costs. General Conference elected not to remove episcopal office expenses of jurisdictional bishops from the Episcopal Fund apportionment but to retain the current practice of apportioning the office expenses of the central conference bishops. The Jurisdictional Study Committee had wanted annual conferences, not the Episcopal Fund, to pay for these expenses, but the legislation failed on the floor 437-254.

Brodie is editor of the South Carolina United Methodist Advocate.

News media contact: Julie Dwyer at (615) 742-5470 or newsdesk@umnews.org. To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free daily or weekly Digests.

United Methodist Bishops bless the elements of Holy Communion during a world-wide worship service at First United Methodist Church in Charlotte, N.C., in the lead-up to the 2024 United Methodist General Conference. From left are Bishops Israel Maestrado Painit of the Philippines, John Wesley Yohanna of Nigeria and Rodolfo A. Juan of the Philippines. The gathering was coordinated by the Love Your Neighbor Coalition and the National Association of Filipino-American United Methodists. Photo by Mike DuBose, UM News. 

General Conference photos

UM News has photographers on the plenary floor of General Conference 2024 and at special events and meetings throughout the session. View photos from each day on Flickr.
See photos

Sign up for our newsletter!

Subscribe Now
Global Health
Dr. Gustave Ngoy, head of the non-malaria program for the Tanganyika Episcopal Area’s medical coordination team, speaks with Cathérine Shabani during a consultation at a mobile clinic in Kalemie, Congo. The 60-year-old mother of 11 children and a member of Jerusalem (United Methodist) Church received a free health checkup as part of a medical initiative funded by Bishop Nelson Kalombo Ngoy to benefit annual conference delegates and vulnerable populations. Photo by Chadrack Tambwe Londe, UM News.

In medical desert, pop-up clinics help Congolese

United Methodist bishop funds annual conference checkups for more than 600 people in a region faced with extreme poverty and limited healthcare.
General Church
The skyline of Calgary in Alberta, Canada. United Methodists from around the globe are coming to the Canadian city for the denomination’s first-of-its-kind Leadership Gathering, scheduled for Oct. 20-24, intended to help the denomination discern its next steps. Photo by Tamsintj, courtesy of Wikimedia Commons.

Countdown begins to Leadership Gathering

Organizers are providing resources to help all United Methodists engage with the gathering intended to help faithfully reimagine the denomination’s future.
General Church
After a season of church disaffiliations, United Methodists are still bringing disputes to civil courts. In the past week, the Baltimore-Washington Conference filed a federal lawsuit to defend the denomination’s trust clause. Meanwhile, Highland Park United Methodist has filed its response to the Horizon Texas Conference lawsuit. Photo illustration by Ray Shrewsberry, Pixabay.

Court cases test United Methodist governance

The Baltimore-Washington Conference filed a federal lawsuit against a church to defend The United Methodist Church’s trust clause. Meanwhile, developments continue in the Texas lawsuit involving Highland Park United Methodist.

United Methodist Communications is an agency of The United Methodist Church

©2026 United Methodist Communications. All Rights Reserved