Judge restricts use of Highland Park name

A Dallas County judge has granted a temporary restraining order in the ongoing legal dispute between the Horizon Texas Conference and Highland Park Methodist, which operates a gothic building adjacent to the Southern Methodist University campus. The ruling blocks a congregation that wishes to remain United Methodist from using “Highland Park” or similar names. Photo courtesy of Highland Park United Methodist Church via Wikipedia.
A Dallas County judge has granted a temporary restraining order in the ongoing legal dispute between the Horizon Texas Conference and Highland Park Methodist, which operates a gothic building adjacent to the Southern Methodist University campus. The ruling blocks a congregation that wishes to remain United Methodist from using “Highland Park” or similar names. Photo courtesy of Highland Park United Methodist Church via Wikipedia.

Key points:

  • A congregation that wishes to remain United Methodist cannot use “Highland Park” or similar names, a judge ruled.
  • A Dallas County judge granted the temporary restraining order in the ongoing legal dispute between the Horizon Texas Conference and Highland Park Methodist, which voted last month to cut ties with the denomination.
  • The pastor of the United Methodist congregation called the news “disappointing,” but he said the congregation remains undeterred.

A Dallas County judge has partially granted Highland Park Methodist Church’s request for a temporary restraining order that blocks United Methodists from using variations of the “Highland Park” name and logos.

The order, which Judge Bridgett Whitmore issued late afternoon Nov. 18, bars the Horizon Texas Conference from “using the names ‘Highland Park United Methodist Church,’ ‘Highland Park United Methodists,’ ‘Highland Park UMC,’ ‘HPUMC,’ ‘HPUMC Oasis,’ or any other designation confusingly similar to the HP Marks.”

However, the order goes on to say that it does not restrict the conference or any person “from gathering for worship, or from operating a congregation under any non-infringing name.”

With the order, the judge has made her first ruling in litigation that has pitted the Horizon Texas Conference against the Dallas megachurch that had been its largest congregation. 

The conference initially filed the lawsuit in August — seeking to bring Highland Park’s governing documents back in line with the Book of Discipline, which contains the denomination’s rules for church administration.

In 2022, Highland Park’s church council revised its bylaws and incorporation documents. Among other changes, the revised documents stripped references to the Discipline and officially modified the church’s name to Highland Park Methodist, while still doing business as “Highland Park United Methodist.” The conference’s lawsuit followed meetings in October, December and March in which Bishop Rubén Saenz Jr. and other conference leaders urged the church council to amend church governing documents. 

The dispute has continued to escalate, and last month, about 90% of 4,775 voting members supported the church council’s resolution to cut ties with the denomination. The total vote involved only about a third of the roughly 15,000 members on Highland Park’s rolls. 

Days after the vote, Saenz announced he was removing the Rev. Matt Tuggle, the church’s current senior pastor, and the Rev. Paul Rasmussen, the senior pastor emeritus, from the church’s leadership. He also announced he was appointing the Rev. Andy Lewis, the assistant to the bishop, to serve as pastor. 

In practical effect, Tuggle has continued leading thousands in worship each Sunday at the church’s longtime location of 3300 Mockingbird Lane under the name Highland Park Methodist Church.

At the same time, Lewis has led worship for more than 100 church members who wish to remain United Methodist under the name “Highland Park United Methodist Church.” For two weeks, that congregation shared space with University Park United Methodist Church, about three miles away.

But starting on Nov. 15, the remnant congregation moved its Sunday services to Southern Methodist University’s Prothro Great Hall. The hall is part of United Methodist-related Perkins School of Theology and across the parking lot from Highland Park Methodist. 

Around the time of the planned move, Highland Park Methodist filed a counterclaim Nov. 10 arguing that by using the name Highland Park United Methodist and related variants for the remnant congregation, the conference was infringing on its trademarks.

In its countersuit, Highland Park Methodist Church asserted that identifying the United Methodist congregation as HPUMC and using Highland Park in its name was causing confusion among the public, including donors. 

Meanwhile, the conference argued that the designation “United Methodist” is only available to ecclesiastically United Methodist ministries and that “Highland Park” is a geographic designation used by numerous communities including the wealthy neighborhood where both congregations are worshipping. 

Judge Whitmore’s order, issued almost a week after a Nov. 12 hearing, seemed to agree with Highland Park Methodist. 

The order blocks the conference and remnant congregation from “soliciting or accepting charitable contributions using the HP Marks or any other confusingly similar designation.”

The temporary injunction also blocks the United Methodist congregation from “operating the website at hpunitedmethodist.org, or any other website, in a manner that displays any of the HP Marks or any other designation confusingly similar to them.” The new congregation immediately took that website down. 

“This news is disappointing, but I want you to hear from me that I remain undeterred in our mission to offer a United Methodist ministry and witness to the Highland Park community and beyond,” Lewis said in an email to the United Methodist congregation. “There is an unmistakable flame of faith and commitment that is burning in our congregation, and this temporary setback will not snuff it out.”

He added that the order will require the church to regroup around its branding but the congregation still plans to hold worship at 10 a.m. U.S. Central time at Prothro Hall.

A spokesperson for Highland Park Methodist said the church is “deeply grateful” for the court’s order. 

“The Court got it exactly right — we wish our neighbors well and respect their right to worship under any name that does not infringe our historic trademarks or confuse the community,” the spokesperson said by email.

“For generations, our congregation has worshiped, served and built a legacy of faith at the corner of Mockingbird and Hillcrest. Our request has always been about protecting that history, the goodwill of our Church, and our congregation from unnecessary confusion.”

The temporary order expires Dec. 2, when the judge has scheduled a hearing with the parties to consider its extension.

Subscribe to our
e-newsletter

Like what you're reading and want to see more? Sign up for our free UM News Digests featuring important news and events in the life of The United Methodist Church.

Keep me informed!

The judge also has scheduled another hearing Dec. 7 to consider the motion from Highland Park Methodist to dismiss the case. A non-jury trial is scheduled Oct. 12, 2027.

The litigation is among multiple lawsuits across the U.S. involving United Methodist policies on property. Going back to the 1790s, the Discipline of The United Methodist Church and its predecessors has maintained that all property is held in trust for the benefit of the whole denomination.

But amid deepening divisions over the status of LGBTQ people in the church, The United Methodist Church offered a temporary release from the trust provision allowing churches to leave with property if they met certain procedural and financial obligations. 

That temporary release lasted between 2019 and 2023. During that time, Highland Park revised its bylaws though it made no other move to withdraw from the denomination. At the same time, some 7,600 congregations — a quarter of the denomination’s U.S. churches — used that temporary release to disaffiliate. 

The Judicial Council, the denomination’s top court, in late 2024 ruled that with the temporary release no longer in the Discipline, the recent season of disaffiliations was over and the trust clause was back in force.

In recent years, several state courts have affirmed the denomination’s trust clause and dismissed suits that asked them to intervene in disaffiliation requirements. However, this month, a South Carolina lower court dismissed 70 cases brought by the South Carolina Conference and local United Methodist churches against congregations seeking to separate from the denomination with property. The conference plans to appeal that ruling. 

The case involving Highland Park remains ongoing. 

“While legal proceedings continue, we remain hopeful that the Horizon Texas Conference will choose a path that respects our congregation and allows both churches to move forward,” the Highland Park spokesperson said. 

Lewis offered a similar message. 

“Friends, let us continue to pray for one another and for a path forward in this situation,” he said in his email. “I am reminded of Paul’s closing words to the Corinthians in chapter 16:13-14: ‘...Stand firm in your faith, be courageous, be strong. Let all that you do be done in love.’”

Hahn is assistant news editor for UM News. Contact her at (615) 742-5470 or newsdesk@umnews.org.To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free UM News Digest.

Sign up for our newsletter!

Subscribe Now
Congregations
Highland Park United Methodists who want to remain part of The United Methodist Church plan to worship at Prothro Great Hall on Southern Methodist University’s campus, starting on Nov. 15. Meanwhile, the legal dispute between the Horizon Texas Conference and breakaway Highland Park Methodist is escalating. Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons, Creative Commons.

Debate heats up over Highland Park name

After voting to cut ties with The United Methodist Church, Highland Park Methodist is asking the court to stop those who wish to remain United Methodist from using the Highland Park name. Meanwhile, the United Methodist congregation is moving locations.
Congregations
Bishop Rubén Saenz Jr. gives the sermon during morning worship at the United Methodist Leadership Gathering Oct. 21 at Knox United Church in Calgary, Canada. The Horizon Texas Conference bishop announced Oct. 29 that he has appointed a new pastor to Highland Park United Methodist Church in Dallas after the church held a congregational vote to cut ties with the denomination. Photo by Mike DuBose, UM News.

Bishop names new pastor to Highland Park

Bishop Rubén Saenz Jr. is making plans to care for Highland Park members who wish to stay United Methodist. In letters to both Highland Park lay leaders and congregants, he also maintained that this week’s congregational vote to cut ties with the denomination is not valid under church law.
Congregations
Members of Highland Park United Methodist Church, which began on the Southern Methodist University campus in Dallas 110 years ago, voted on Oct. 25-26 to sever ties with The United Methodist Church. Photo courtesy of Highland Park United Methodist Church via Wikipedia.

Highland Park votes to leave United Methodist Church

After two days of voting, members of the Dallas congregation overwhelmingly approved a resolution severing ties with The United Methodist Church. More than 90% voted in favor of the move, according to the church.

United Methodist Communications is an agency of The United Methodist Church

©2026 United Methodist Communications. All Rights Reserved